Happy Birthday to...
| Author | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Basiate |
HPV Vaccine |
Lead | |
|
the govt should be allowed to make this a vaccine 6th grade girls have to get?
|
|||
Sword of Honor |
HPV Vaccine | ||
|
No.
1. HPV is not a disease contracted by the average teenage girl. It's essentially a sexually-transmitted disease and hoochies are more likely to get it than "nice" girls. 2. The government has no authority to tell parents what drugs to put into their children's bodies. |
|||
IcarusSafire |
HPV Vaccine | ||
|
No.
|
|||
Dalek Magi |
Re: HPV Vaccine | ||
|
No government mandates on HPV are acceptable. This is an unproven vaccine for a sexually-transmitted disease, and it's made from Rat Poison. I tell you, there is going to be a rash of girls with infertility or sterility problems in about 10 years because of this vaccine!
|
|||
Alvida |
|||
|
'Nice girls' can easily get cervical cancer if their partner has been playing away, whereas if they'd had the HPV vaccine they'd be protected.
I don't have a problem with the age they are suggesting because the rubella jab was given to 12-13 year old girls, it wasn't assumed they were having
sex it was just deemed the best time to give the vaccine, as is the case with the HPV vaccine, it works better if it's administered in the early teens.
|
|||
ashrickley |
|||
|
I won't permit the school to administer the shot to my daughter when she's 12 or 13. I will however tell her on my own volition the seriousnes of
having sex at that age and the consequences of contracting HPV. If she still decides to have sex then she'll have to deal with those possibilities in her
life.
|
|||
SteelyEyes |
|||
|
Make it available but not mandatory. People have the right to be ignorant and make poor decisions about their kid's health.
|
|||
Penel0pe |
|||
|
Cosigned what steelyEyes says - Nice girls can get HPV too. Males can go around and screw anything they can get their hands on, and they are "Studs."
Girls can have ONE boyfriend, and take the risk of cervical cancer as a result. This makes them "Hootchy Mamas." The reality of HPV is that something like 2/3's of adults have been exposed. Only the women run the risk of cancer. Make the vaccine available, and give parents information - INFORMED denial / consent is better than outright ignorance any day. I don't think any kind of vaccine should be given to anyone's child without parental consent, but parents need to get real and understand the world our kids live in today - and C'mon. We're not so far from that world ourselves - I remember the 70's, and I don't recall too many Puritans at my high school. As it stands today, there is no reason that any woman in a developed nation should ever die from cervical cancer - but cervical dysplasia is a common condition, and that is the result of HPV (Cervical dysplasia is abnormal cells / precancerous cells of the cervix.) So, the "Stud" gets to go around and infect as many women as he wants to and is essentially asymptomatic (Unless, god willing, he develops genital warts.) Otherwise, some girl who has had ONE boyfriend can develop cancer as a result of choosing a partner who has HPV, because he's such a stud... or even because he had ONE other girlfriend before her. Even a "Nice Boy" can infect a "Nice Girl." It's a disease, not a social condition. There's dreamland, and then there's the world we really live in. |
|||
Propaganster |
|||
SteelyEyes wrote:I tend to agree with this solution. |
|||
CPU EvilGenius |
|||
|
Even if the vaccine WAS effective, it's only supposed to last about 15 years, and young women aged 15-30 don't get cervical cancer; older women do.
|
|||
didanyoneusethis |
|||
|
Last I checked, it was 11 deaths of children and young women and counting, and thousands of bad reactions.
They're not sure how well or how long it will provide any level of protection, and it could be as little as five years. Currently, about 2,500 US women per year die of cervical cancer, and most are old enough to be post menopause. That might sound like a lot, but breast cancer takes the life of about 30,000 women. This shot doesn't promise protection from all HPV strains, and it doesn't promise protection from all cervical cancer. It could very well INCREASE cervical cancer deaths by giving vaccinated women a false sense of security that causes them to delay or not bother with yearly pap tests. |
|||
NMOCM |
|||
Dalek Magi wrote:
I've thought about the same thing. |
|||